So, how do you raise a child who responds with prompt and cheerful (first-time) obedience? Who speaks respectfully with "yes, ma'am" and "no, sir" and greets guests with a smile and eye contact? How do you encourage self-discipline and creativity? How do you teach them to think through the consequences of their actions, develop healthy relationships, be confident, secure, forgiving? How do you introduce them to God? How do you cultivate a good relationship with them that transitions from parent to friend in adulthood? How do you create a home of order and wonder?
There are so many different theories on this! And it's my tendency to look for The Right Way. All the books have roughly the same goal (virtuous adults), all say that parents will make mistakes, and of course each family / child is different. But the methods differ so much that I just don't know what to make of it right now.
I just read a book called
Parenting with Love and Logic. It promotes using natural consequences, logical consequences and time-outs (as an extension of a logical consequence.) I really like the emphasis on letting experience teach the child, and then truly empathizing with his poor choice (if he makes one). That way, the punishment is felt internally, and the kid blames himself (not the parent); he has to take responsibility for his own actions. You learn by doing, internalizing and thinking! Very Socratic. I also like the idea of relinquishing control, in gradual degrees, until the kid is a late teen and is capable of making wise choices for himself.
One take-away: give G a choice in her clothes (even if she isn't asking to choose them), ask if she'd rather "carry or wear" her coat to the car, etc.
But, does this approach deal effectively with whining, non-compliance in preschoolers and open defiance? (Grace really doesn't do these things very often, but they occur occasionally.) Is it fair to say "I'll get back to you about that," and come up with a consequence later, when it presents itself? ("I asked you nicely to go to your room and you didn't, so now when you're asking me nicely to go to the zoo, we won't.") That's the same logic that Kevin Lehman uses in Have a New Kid by Friday, and it just doesn't sit well with me. (To be fair, I think these authors are suggesting that tactic with an older child.) Also, I have trouble letting a child make a choice with a logical consequence that would hurt her (ie, "you may be excused, and perhaps the next meal will appeal to you more" and then letting the picky eater go hungry at bedtime.)
This book outlines a good tool for the tool box, and one I maybe should use more often. But I'll wait to discuss with David to see if it will be one we use right now.